Studio Owners

Studio Biz: Are Your Workers Employees or Contractors? Here's How You Know

Getty Images

Accountant Jessica Scheitler, founder of Financial Groove, has noticed a recent trend. More and more of her dance-studio-owner clients are being audited because of the way they classify faculty and staff—whether as employees or contractors. "I had four or five audits come in at the same time, all from different states," she says. "That tells me something's going on."

Studio owners tend to first hire faculty as contractors, Scheitler notes, since that's the easiest route. "You cut someone a check, and you don't have to take taxes out," she explains. "But as studios grow, most teachers and staff end up qualifying to be employees in the eyes of the government. And if you're audited and the IRS finds that your staff should be paid as employees, they'll assess back taxes—and interest."


Changing a classification from contractor to employee isn't cheap—Scheitler estimates that the out-of-pocket cost is 12 percent. Though this figure could fluctuate, based on what state you live in, you'll now be responsible for matching your employee's Social Security and Medicare withholdings. You'll also need to pay in to Federal Unemployment Tax and State Unemployment Tax. (Some states require businesses to pay for workers' compensation, too.) The additional expense is offset somewhat because you'll be able to write it off on your business return. It might also afford you peace of mind. "Yes, it's a financial commitment," she says, "but it might also help a studio owner not lose sleep over a potential audit."

But automatically switching everyone over to employee status as a safeguard isn't necessarily the answer. The best way to protect yourself from an audit is to understand the law and decide what strategy fits your business. "Everybody has a specific situation—so we assess it person by person," Scheitler says.

Contractor vs. Employee: What Does It Mean?

In simple terms, if someone working at your studio is classified as a contractor, that means you're not taking any taxes out of their pay—that teacher or staff member is responsible for paying taxes on their own. When someone is an employee, you, as the business owner, are required to withhold local, state and federal taxes from their paychecks and deposit with the IRS on the employees' behalf. You are also required to match their contributions to Social Security and Medicare.

Contractor or Employee? 10 Qs to Help You Figure It Out

Determining whether your faculty and staff are contractors or employees is based on three factors, says accountant Jessica Scheitler: behavior—how the teacher performs her or his job; finances—who controls the salary; and relationship—the length of time someone's been working for you, and if they're working for anyone else.

Answering the questions below can point you in the right direction. But even this method isn't foolproof. "If it ends up being six answers in the contractor column and four in the employee column for the same person, I would say, 'OK, what else can we get in the contractor column?'" Scheitler says. "That way, you feel comfortable with it."

1. How many hours do they work each week? The fewer hours they work at your studio, the more likely they are to be classified as contractors. "If they're working 40 hours a week for you, you're the main gig," says Scheitler—and they are an employee.

2. Did you train them in the style or technique they teach? If you did, they're probably an employee. "But if you brought Debbie in because she has the specific tap style you want to introduce to your students, and you can't find someone to teach this style anywhere else, and you don't know how to do it, that helps to define her as a contractor," says Scheitler.

3. Who sets the schedule? This can be a difficult question to answer. "If you're saying, 'I need someone on Tuesdays at 5:15,'" says Scheitler, "then you're setting the schedule, and they're your employee." Guest choreographers who travel to your studio and come in only for a short period of time, meanwhile, are classic contractors. If a teacher says, for example, that she can only do Fridays at 7, that would also be a contractor classification.

4. How are they paid? "If someone is presenting their rate of pay to you, take it or leave it, then they're a contractor," says Scheitler. "If you say, 'I've got this position, and I can only pay $20 an hour,' that's an employee."

5. Do they have more than one teaching job? An employee would be someone who works exclusively at your studio and earns the majority of their living by teaching for you. If a faculty member is teaching at several other studios, that would indicate they have their own business and are freelancing—therefore qualifying as a contractor.

6. Do they provide their own music? "Most of the time, faculty bring in their own phones or devices," Scheitler says, "so they'd be contractors." If you require your teachers to play specific music—for example, if your baby classes must be taught to tracks you've purchased as part of a curriculum—that would make them employees.

7. Who decides the rate for their services? A contractor would decide her or his rates (though that's not to say you can't negotiate that rate).

8. How do they submit hours to be paid? "Your contractors need to be invoicing you," says Scheitler. "That's not to say that you can't track their hours, or that they can't submit them through your studio management system, but technically they need to present an invoice to you."

9. Do they have a contract? Ideally, a contractor would provide you with a contract stating the parameters of their terms—though Scheitler admits that rarely happens. It's important to note, too, that a contract must stipulate that the contractor is providing their own liability insurance and/or workers' compensation.

10. How often are they paid? "A contractor would give you an invoice that says, 'This is due by the fifth,'" says Scheitler, whereas for an employee, you'd decide when to cut the checks. "Again, there's room for negotiation," she says.

Dance News
Getty Images

Dancers are resilient by nature. As our community responds to COVID-19, that spirit is being tested. Dance Teacher acknowledges the tremendous challenges you face for your teaching practice and for your schools as you bring your offerings online, and the resulting financial impact on your businesses.

Perhaps we can take hope from the knowledge of how we've managed adversity in the past. I'm thinking of the dance community in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. I'm thinking of 9/11 and how that changed the world. I'm thinking of the courageous Jarrah Myles who kept her students safe when the Paradise wildfire destroyed their homes. I'm thinking of Jana Monson who rebuilt her studio after a devastating fire. I'm thinking of Gina Gibney who stepped in to save space for dance in New York City when the beloved Dance New Amsterdam closed.

Keep reading... Show less
Sponsored by Dance Teacher Web
Courtesy Dance Teacher Web

While summer usually sparks dreams of warm vacations in the sun, many dance teachers don't have the luxury of taking a week off to lounge by the pool. But what if a stellar educational opportunity for dance instructors just happened to take place in sunny Las Vegas?

The Dance Teacher Web Conference and Expo, happening August 4–7 and founded and directed by longtime successful studio owners and master teachers Steve Sirico and Angela D'Valda Sirico, gives dance teachers and administrators a chance to learn, network and recharge during a one-of-a-kind working vacation. Here, attendees can rub shoulders with esteemed industry professionals, get inspired by a variety of workshops and even walk away with a new certification or two:

Keep reading... Show less
Studio Owners
Photo courtesy of Misty Lown

Please join us for a Virtual Town Hall with Misty Lown, owner of More Than Just Great Dancing, an affiliation of 300 studios worldwide, and Youth Protection Advocates in Dance. She's also a dance studio owner of 23 years.

Register here to join the call for Monday, March 30, at 1 pm CST (2 pm, EDT).

Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teacher Tips
Getty Images

On Wednesday, March 18, I was supposed to return to Juilliard and teach Pilates after a two-week spring break. Instead, I rolled a mat onto my bedroom floor, logged in to Zoom and was greeted by a gallery of 50 small-screen images of young ambitious dancers, trying to make the best of a strange situation. As I began class, I applied our new catchphrase: "Please mute yourself," then asked students to use various hand gestures to let me know how they are coping and how much space they have for movement. I asked dancers to write one or two things they wanted to address in the sidebar, and then we began to move.

This is our new normal. In the midst of grave Covid-19 concerns, dance professors across the country faced university closures and requirements to relocate their courses to the virtual sphere. Online education poses very specific and substantial challenges to dance faculty, but they are finding ways to persist by learning new methods of communication, discovering untapped pedagogical tools, expanding their professional networks, developing helpful new resources and unearthing old ones.

Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teacher Tips
Choreographer Molly Heller with musician Michael Wall. Photo by Duhaime Movement Project

Love electronic music? Calming notes of a piano? Smooth, rich trumpet? Want music in clear meters of 3, or in 7? This week is the ideal time to check out musician Michael Wall's abundant website soundformovement.com. I myself have enjoyed getting to experience his music over the past five years—whether to use in a teen class, older-movers class or for my own MFA thesis choreography.

Keep reading... Show less
Site Network
Courtesy of Wroth

The effects of COVID-19 on college dancers might have been devastating. Performances were canceled, seniors trying to savor every last moment together were left without a graduation ceremony, students were encouraged to go home, and at each moment, a question has sounded: How can a student learn how to become a better performer when they are not allowed to perform?

Here at Indiana University's Jacobs School of Music, the ballet department rallied quickly and adapted its programming, choosing to see this hiatus as an opportunity to encourage reflection and self-improvement.

Keep reading... Show less
Site Network
Getty Images

As Broadway goes dark and performances are canceled across the country, the financial repercussions of a global pandemic have gone from hypothetical to very real. This is especially true in the dance community, where many institutions are nonprofits or small businesses operating on thin margins, and performers rely on gigs that are being canceled. It's a scary and uncertain time.

Keep reading... Show less
Getty Images

Q: We always seem to lose the most students after our recitals. How do I prevent post-show fallout?

Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teacher Tips
Getty Images

With studio closures and shelter-in-place restrictions throughout the country this week due to COVID-19 concerns, dancers are putting creative skills to use in a myriad of new ways with each given day and new scenario. If you are stuck at home, consider a few of these projects that frequently get pushed down our long "to do" lists.

Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teachers Trending
Alicia Graf Mack. Photo by Rachel Papo


American Ballet Theatre principal dancer James Whiteside is doing his best to adjust to life at home during the coronavirus outbreak. Watch below for his insights, and see who among the ballet world's best is teaching online, including DT's January cover star and director of The Juilliard School's Dance Division, Alicia Graf Mack (minute 1:07).


Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teachers Trending
Nyama McCarthy-Brown leads class. Courtesy of McCarthy-Brown

For the past 20 years, Ohio State University professor Nyama McCarthy-Brown has been advocating for dance pedagogy that embraces students' cultural backgrounds. "When you look at a textbook and all you see is Western-based dances or people moving in ways that point back to a Eurocentric culture, how do you value other cultures?" she asks. "How do we value other cultures when we're not seeing them in every place that we're told is important?"

In her 2017 book Dance Pedagogy for a Diverse World: Culturally Relevant Teaching in Theory, Research and Practice, McCarthy-Brown details her approach, which hinges on researching the cultural backgrounds of the students in the room and teaching with these in mind. Integrating students' cultural practices into dance curriculum, especially in K–12 schools, enables students to be seen and valued, and to have a more positive learning experience.

Keep reading... Show less
Dance Teachers Trending
Photo courtesy of Damrow

Kristin Damrow is a beloved teaching artist in the San Francisco Bay Area. On average, she teaches 15 hours a week with adults and teens of different levels, plus directs her company Kristin Damrow & Company. She is also a tech-savvy artist who makes vlogs and maximizes social-media posts through Facebook and Instagram to support her teaching and choreographic work. Her dance work is already well-connected via technology.

This week we asked Kristin a few questions as she posted her first online teaching video, in light of the COVID-19 outbreak and the closing of all institutions in which she teaches.

Keep reading... Show less

mailbox

Get DanceTeacher in your inbox