Teaching Tips

Susan Pilarre Explains 5 Balanchine Essential Elements

Susan Pilarre has been closely tied to the School of American Ballet for nearly her entire life.

From her first class there at age 11 through her 16-year career with its affiliated company, New York City Ballet, Pilarre learned directly from the great choreographer George Balanchine, absorbing the details of his unique style. Sensing her innate understanding of his principles, Balanchine encouraged her to teach; she joined SAB's permanent faculty in 1986. Since then, she has become recognized as an authority on Balanchine's teachings, instilling SAB and NYCB's distinctive speed, clarity and energy into generations of dancers.

Here, Pilarre shares how the specifics that Balanchine insisted upon in class contribute to the strength, beauty and musicality that define his style—and dispels common misconceptions.


1 "Every step is a sandwich on plié bread"

"Plié is completely paramount in Balanchine technique," says Pilarre. "You don't have anything without it. I often say every step is a sandwich on plié bread." To achieve the pliant, elastic quality Balanchine wanted (he famously urged his dancers to land as softly as cats), he had them land jumps with their weight forward over their toes, never quite letting their heels touch the floor—not actively picking them up, as is commonly misperceived. When executing a demi-plié from a standing position, he asked for a slight release of the heels.

"The misunderstanding is that people think you lift your heels and let them come way off the ground," Pilarre says. "Mr. B used to say, 'Slip a piece of paper under your heels.' It's important for soft landings that your torso is forward, in front of your hips, that you land in your toes."

2 A pirouette surprise

One of Balanchine's core objectives was to de-emphasize, or hide, preparations. "He didn't want us to broadcast 'Now I will pirouette,'" Pilarre explains. He thought the traditional fourth position in demi-plié encouraged "sitting" in the preparation, slightly delaying takeoff and disrupting the flow of movement. "One day he said, 'We're not going to turn like that anymore.' He wanted us to simply tombé into a long fourth position, as if we were going to do another step, and then voilá—you just turned. The pirouette comes out of nowhere." She adds that while the back leg is straight, it should not be not stiff.

3 Spot for the audience

Spotting the front, another Balanchine trademark, was intended to better present the dancer and engage the audience, particularly during turns along the diagonal. "Spotting the wing advertises that you're about to exit," she says. "It's all about the people we're performing for. You're not performing for the wings."

4 "The wrists and elbows are a team"

Balanchine wanted his dancers to sculpt their hands like pieces of art, shaping each finger individually. "The cup of the hand is rounded, and the thumb and pinky are completely separated from the other fingers, but they're not stiff. You should be able to wiggle your fingers," says Pilarre. Épaulement, intrinsically coordinated with the arms and hands, was particularly important to him—the look includes a gracefully curved neck, as if offering one's cheek for a kiss.

Elbows and wrists are supple and move with energy and intention, "taking" the dancer into each step. They often cross as they move through positions. "The joints move a lot, but with strength," says Pilarre. "The wrists and elbows are a team: You bring the elbows in, lift the wrists and the hands go up, and reverse that to bring them down." In a piqué arabesque, for example, she teaches students to lead, energetically, with the hand, arm and head. "You're always moving with your head and hands first, initiating it. It's more exciting-looking, and it creates musicality that you don't get if the hands are droopy or drippy."

5 Move, fly, spring into action

Balanchine ballets are known for their speed, which is why quickness is built into SAB training. Pilarre begins her classes with grands pliés (in only two counts each) and always includes multiple tendu combinations, each faster than the last, to train the students' feet to point very swiftly and strongly (toes pulling back sharply from tendu devant) for maximum attack in petit allégro. "The feet should point so fast no one even sees them go out there," she says.

In Balanchine's choreography, the accent is often down, on count 1 (putting emphasis on the plié), with an upward impetus just afterward. In class, Pilarre stresses counting all parts of each measure to teach students to be acutely aware of accents. "Counting is essential for musicality," she says. "I actually sing the counts in every single exercise I give, not just the 1 and the 2, but the 'ands' in between. Mr. B said you should see the music and hear the dance, but he also said the most important thing is to be on time. So I teach that right away, starting at barre."

The underlying concept is about more than simply moving fast, though. It's about readiness, says Pilarre, and creating a series of clear, vivid pictures as you dance. "Mr. B wanted dancers to be ready to move, to fly, to spring into action. To be on the balls of the feet, so you arrive at your destination on time and not a nanosecond later. That's what makes his ballet so exciting—the speed and the brilliance."

Teaching Tips
A 2019 Dancewave training. Photo by Effy Grey, courtesy Dancewave

By now, most dance educators hopefully understand that they have a responsibility to address racism in the studio. But knowing that you need to be actively cultivating racial equity isn't the same thing as knowing how to do so.

Of course, there's no easy answer, and no perfect approach. As social justice advocate David King emphasized at a recent interactive webinar, "Cultivating Racial Equity in the Classroom," this work is never-ending. The event, hosted by Dancewave (which just launched a new racial-equity curriculum) was a good starting point, though, and offered some helpful takeaways for dance educators committed to racial justice.

Keep reading... Show less
Higher Ed
The author, Robyn Watson. Photo courtesy Watson

Recently, I posted a thread of tweets elucidating the lack of respect for tap dance in college dance programs, and arguing that it should be a requirement for dance majors.

According to onstageblog.com, out of the 30 top-ranked college dance programs in the U.S., tap dance is offered at 19 of them, but only one school requires majors to take more than a beginner course—Oklahoma City University. Many prestigious dance programs, like the ones at NYU Tisch School of the Arts and SUNY Purchase, don't offer a single course in tap dance.

Keep reading... Show less
Teaching Tips
Getty Images

After months of lockdowns and virtual learning, many studios across the country are opening their doors and returning to in-person classes. Teachers and students alike have likely been chomping at the bit in anticipation of the return of dance-class normalcy that doesn't require a reliable internet connection or converting your living room into a dance space.

But along with the back-to-school excitement, dancers might be feeling rusty from being away from the studio for so long. A loss of flexibility, strength and stamina is to be expected, not to mention emotional fatigue from all of the uncertainty and reacclimating to social activities.

So as much as everyone wants to get back to normal—teachers and studio owners included—erring on the side of caution with your dancers' training will be the most beneficial approach in the long run.

Keep reading... Show less

Get Dance Business Weekly in your inbox

Sign Up Used in accordance with our Privacy Policy.