Health & Body

Ask Deb: "Can the Hips Truly Be Square in Fourth and Fifth Positions?"


Like many dancers, I was taught to hold my hips square when standing in fourth and fifth positions. However, in a recent professional development course, I was told the following:

"The hips cannot anatomically be square in fourth or fifth. The dancer must not try to hold them square—it is neither possible nor desirable. For pliés and all other movements in fourth, the pelvis will rotate toward the back leg. Rather than squaring off the hips, allow the hips to swing toward the back leg and square off the shoulders from the upper spine."

I would appreciate your input on this. —Katie

Dear Katie,

Try this: Stand in first position (hips squared) and tendu your right foot to the side. Slowly draw it into third position, maintaining your turnout. Notice how your pelvis begins to rotate to the left as you continue to cross your foot into a closed fifth position. The same thing happens when you move into a crossed fourth position.

Anatomically, the less range of motion in the hips, the greater the tendency to rotate the pelvis. And yet, I teach my students to think of their pelvis squaring off because I believe it sets up better muscle patterning.

In order to keep dancers working safely, I don't teach a closed fourth position, and I ask dancers to find their fifth position by paying close attention to their weight on both feet. They should keep their weight balanced between the three points of the foot (inner and outer ball of the foot and the heel) and equally distributed between both feet. This way, they learn where their turnout is and avoid turning out from the knee down.

For younger children, I like to teach barre without the barre. They learn very quickly how to stand on their legs without using the barre to hold positions that are anatomically impossible. They learn to distribute their weight throughout the whole foot and not pronate (roll in).

This isn't a black-and-white situation. My short answer would be to maintain squareness as much as your individual turnout allows. The key is learning to use the turnout you have.

I'm reminded of a very influential experience in my own dance history. I was taking ballet from Maggie Black in New York City some years ago. There was a male soloist in class. I would stand near him at the barre and observe that he stood in approximately 45 degrees of turnout in each leg in first position. But when he went out into center, he moved so beautifully that I didn't notice that his turnout was average. His carriage and performance were so engaging.

I will be forever grateful to that dancer and Maggie Black who gave me permission to have less-than-perfect turnout, train to my body's structure and improve slowly, safely and surely.

To your success,

Deborah Vogel

Director, The Body Series

Got a question for Deb? E-mail, and she may answer it in an upcoming web exclusive.

Getty Images

Despite worldwide theater closures, the Universal Ballet Competition is keeping The Nutcracker tradition alive in 2020 with an online international competition. The event culminates in a streamed, full-length video of The Virtual Nutcracker consisting of winning entries on December 19. The competition is calling on studios, as well as dancers of all ages and levels, to submit videos by November 29 to be considered.

"Nutcracker is a tradition that is ingrained in our hearts," says UBC co-founder Lissette Salgado-Lucas, a former dancer with Royal Winnipeg Ballet and Joffrey Ballet. "We danced it for so long as professionals, we can't wait to pass it along to dancers through this competition."

Keep reading... Show less
Robbie Sweeny, courtesy Funsch

Christy Funsch's teaching career has taken her from New York City to the Bay Area to Portugal, with a stint in a punk band in between. But this fall—fresh off a Fulbright in Portugal at the Instituto Politécnico de Lisboa, School of Dance (ESD), teaching and researching empathetic embodiment through somatic dance training—Funsch's teaching has taken her to an entirely new location: Zoom. A visiting professor at Slippery Rock University for the 2020–21 academic year, Funsch is adapting her eclectic, boundary-pushing approach to her virtual classes.

Originally from central New York State, Funsch spent 20 years performing in the Bay Area, where she also started her own company, Funsch Dance Experience. "My choreographic work from that time is in the dance-theater experiential, fantasy realm of performance," she says. "I also started blending genres and a lot of urban styles found their way into my choreography."

Keep reading... Show less
Courtesy Meg Brooker

As the presidential election approaches, it's a particularly meaningful time to remember that we are celebrating the centennial of the 19th Amendment, when women earned the right to vote after a decades-long battle.

Movement was more than a metaphor for the fight for women's suffrage—dancers played a real role, most notably Florence Fleming Noyes, who performed her riveting solo Dance of Freedom in 1914 to embody the struggle for women's rights.

This fall, Middle Tennessee State University director of dance Meg Brooker is reconstructing Dance of Freedom on 11 of her students. A Noyes Rhythm teacher and an Isadora Duncan scholar, Brooker is passionate about bringing historic dance practices into a contemporary context.

Keep reading... Show less

Get Dance Business Weekly in your inbox

Sign Up Used in accordance with our Privacy Policy.